Matt A
Smile. Or Else.
You know, I'm really rather impressed. It's fair to say that most writers form a bit of a bond with their work: regardless of its objective quality, if you criticise a story, then you critcise its creator. And you best prepare for pain. I mean, I like to think of myself as mature, but even I sulk over my work.
But you? Me and Jack didn't exactly lay into your story - personally, I always try be best to be nice about these things - but we were definitely far harsher than usual. I was expecting you to throw an epic hissy over it, an "I put my heart and soul into this, and this is how you repay me!" kind of thing...but no, not only do you agree, you chastise us for not being harsh enough! Considering how you've represented yourself in the past, I shouldn't have been surprised here, but I was. I ain't sure whether you're masochistic, insane or just a Zen master, but it's still nice to see someone be so open about this sort of thing.
Which is why, it must be said, this finale re-do is the best decision you could've possibly made. I have an essay I need to write - not that I want to, but I don't have a choice - so I'll have to keep my thoughts on this fairly brief...but, needless to say, the two new chapters are a major improvement. Kiryu takes a backseat, a complete non-role in fact, to finally give Sergei another moment to shine, and he sure doesn't waste it: he isn't exactly evil, just selfish, spiteful and vicious enough to count as same.
More to the point, arranging a televised 693-2 mega-brawl as a bet is pretty damn insane, and clear signs of a man with one hell of a sense of humour...especially 'cause, even if Cipher and Raven pull off a miracle and win, there's no guarantee that he'll keep to his word and let them go.
In other words, if you're going to up the scale, this is a pretty fool-proof way to do it.
Oh yes...like Jack, I'm going to have to mention Raven's Star Wars rant. Except, unlike him, I really enjoyed it: it was surprising, sure, and maybe a little pointless, but also very, very funny. Partly 'cause it was indeed unexpected, but mostly 'cause I just find epic swearing binges funny.
And I wouldn't really say it was out of character, 'cause if it wasn't for the fact that Raven is a character in a kid's cartoon, I reckon she'd be a lot less judicious over her language. Either way, it was fairly inspired.
So, with a little frank judgement and putting in some extra hours, you've turned a crap finale into one that's shaping up to pretty damn respectable. All we need to do now is see where you take this next, and if you can keep it up.
-Matt A-
But you? Me and Jack didn't exactly lay into your story - personally, I always try be best to be nice about these things - but we were definitely far harsher than usual. I was expecting you to throw an epic hissy over it, an "I put my heart and soul into this, and this is how you repay me!" kind of thing...but no, not only do you agree, you chastise us for not being harsh enough! Considering how you've represented yourself in the past, I shouldn't have been surprised here, but I was. I ain't sure whether you're masochistic, insane or just a Zen master, but it's still nice to see someone be so open about this sort of thing.
Which is why, it must be said, this finale re-do is the best decision you could've possibly made. I have an essay I need to write - not that I want to, but I don't have a choice - so I'll have to keep my thoughts on this fairly brief...but, needless to say, the two new chapters are a major improvement. Kiryu takes a backseat, a complete non-role in fact, to finally give Sergei another moment to shine, and he sure doesn't waste it: he isn't exactly evil, just selfish, spiteful and vicious enough to count as same.
In other words, if you're going to up the scale, this is a pretty fool-proof way to do it.
Oh yes...like Jack, I'm going to have to mention Raven's Star Wars rant. Except, unlike him, I really enjoyed it: it was surprising, sure, and maybe a little pointless, but also very, very funny. Partly 'cause it was indeed unexpected, but mostly 'cause I just find epic swearing binges funny.
So, with a little frank judgement and putting in some extra hours, you've turned a crap finale into one that's shaping up to pretty damn respectable. All we need to do now is see where you take this next, and if you can keep it up.
-Matt A-


