Greatest Book Ever!

[jph139]

Yarr, I'll go with Treasure Island, too.

 

[Comics_the_QB]

Treasure Island wins 4-1

Next: Dracula vs. The Hound of Baskervilles

Really tough, but I am going with Baskervilles on this one.

(BTW, it seems that I screwed up again. Turns out we'll have to put up with 1 more match of book vs. book vs. book. Then we'll play it out differently in the next round. Again, sorry)

 

[jph139]

Hmm... while Sherlock Holmes IS amazing, I think Dracula has been more influential as a whole, while as a book I'd put it slightly behind.

 

[The Cartoon]

Incredibly tough decision. I'm half tempted to actually skip this round, but I think I'll go ahead and say Dracula.

 

[Prof. Mecavio]

"The Hound of the Baskervilles" for me.

 

[Comics_the_QB]

It's a tie.

 

[Bloody Marquis]

Baskervilles

 

[Comics_the_QB]

Baskervilles wins 3-2

Next: Alice's Adventures in Wonderland vs. To Kill a Mockingbird

I like them both, but my vote goes to Mockingbird.

 

[jph139]

Yeah, Mockingbird. Alice is great, but it's a bit too fluffy for my tastes.

 

[The Cartoon]

To Kill a Mockingbird. For Alice, I liked the movie more than the book.

 

[Urusei Yatsura]

Mockingbird it is.

 

[Gold Guy]

Alice for me.

 

[Tomato Surprise]

Alice

Tomato

 

[Comics_the_QB]

Mockingbird wins 4-2

This match will play like the last bvbvb did. You will vote for the one you want out of the competition. Next round will play out the same, except you'll have 5 books to choose from instead of 3.

That being said: Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy vs. Neverwhere vs. The Phantom Tollbooth

I'll vote out Phantom Tollbooth.

 

[MonkeyFunk]

Tollbooth

 

[The Cartoon]

Neverwhere, I love it but I think that the other 2 are better.

 

[jph139]

Yeah, let's bid farewell to Tollbooth.

 

[cradleman]

goodbye to tollbooth for me as well

 

[Prof. Mecavio]

"Toolbooth", because I haven't read it.

 

[Bloody Marquis]

Tollbooth