Well, really, Dragon Crisis and Dream Eater Merry look to bleh to me; Fractale sorta pretty much have the same problem as GOSICK (as you can see, me and male leads don't seem to be a good fit, mostly because they steal too much the spotlight in both shows); Infinite Stratos may count as that, too; FREEZING is way too risky to watch, so this leaves me with: (not counting Mitsudomoe)
- Onii-chan no Koto ga Zenzen Suki Janain Dakara ne (a show I wasn't even planning on watching, and then GANSIS was apperantly involved...and the first episode was ridiculously good)
- Rio - Rainbow Gate
- Kore wa Zombie wa desu ka (BTW, score yet another flawed Yoko Hikasa role. Why? I hate Sera)
- Magical Girl Madoka Magica (my fault, I cannot believe I forgot to include this one on the title hunt, actually.)
So it's either Madoka or Rio, actually.